Anthony Ionadi, the first Italian - period.
Anthony not only has "spunk and pizzazz" (by the way, I don't think you made the word "pizzazz" up..defs heard it before lol), but the experience to become a reality TV star. He is recognizable enough from hosting various TV programs and specials - like on Global News - so that can benefit in his brand and practising talent on Lake Shore, not to mention bringing up their ratings.
He has spiky hair, a tanned complexion, and a slim build...Should he be crowned "Pauly D" or "Vinny" here? Thoughts?!